Cart 0

Welcome to The Buttermilk Bakery Online Store!

Thank you for visiting! We are taking custom orders. Please reach out if you have any questions on Facebook Messenger or via email buttermilkbakedgoods@gmail.com Thank You!

Featured collection

More valentine's day! ›
Valentine's Cookie Sets

Valentine's Cookie Sets
8 Chocolate Covered Oreos

8 Chocolate Covered Oreos
Buckeyes

Buckeyes
Valentine's Macaron Flight

Valentine's Macaron Flight
Mini Cookie Cakes

Mini Cookie Cakes
Cake Pops

Cake Pops
Fresh Baked Jumbo Cookie Flight

Fresh Baked Jumbo Cookie Flight
Custom Cookie Order

Custom Cookie Order
1 dozen decorated minis- only available as add on to cookie order

1 dozen decorated minis- only available as add on to cookie order

The Buttermilk Bakery is an online based special order bakery located in Littlestown, PA. We specialize in custom decorated cookies. Items are available for local pickup.