Welcome to The Buttermilk Bakery Online Store!
Thank you for visiting! We are currently taking limited custom orders for November, and December. October is completely booked besides Halloween Orders. There is an updated availability calendar on our Facebook page. Contact us via email or messenger with any questions.
We have adjusted our prices slightly due to the rising cost of ingredients. Thank you so much for supporting us. We love being part of all of your special days.
The Buttermilk Bakery is an online based special order bakery located in Littlestown, PA. We specialize in custom decorated cookies but also offer special occasion cakes and other seasonal baked goods. All items are available for local pickup, some items are available for nationwide shipping.