Need a Custom Order? Click here!

Sign in or Create an Account

Home
Custom Cookies
- Decorated Cookies
- 1 dozen decorated minis- only available as add on to cookie order
Christmas
Party Platters
Events
Contact Us
Sign in
Create an Account

Home
Custom Cookies
- Decorated Cookies
- 1 dozen decorated minis- only available as add on to cookie order
Christmas
Party Platters
Events
Contact Us
Sign in
Create an Account

Home › Christmas 2025

Shop By

Christmas
Seasonal

Christmas 2025

Sort by

Cozy Christmas Cookies

Cozy Christmas Cookies

Regular price $40⁰⁰ $40.00

DIY Decorating Kit

DIY Decorating Kit

Regular price $18⁰⁰ $18.00

Christmas Trees

Christmas Trees

Regular price $30⁰⁰ $30.00

Elf Cookies

Regular price $5⁰⁰ $5.00

Paint Your Own Christmas Cookies

Paint Your Own Christmas Cookies

Regular price $4⁰⁰ $4.00

Holiday Simmer Pot

Holiday Simmer Pot

Regular price $10⁰⁰ $10.00

Shop

Custom Cookies
Christmas
Party Platters
Events
Contact Us

Contact Information

buttermilkbakedgoods@gmail.com

Littlestown, PA

Be the First to Know!

Be the first to know about seasonal orders and special pre-orders! Directly to your inbox.

Email

Facebook
Instagram

© 2025 Buttermilk Bakery
Powered by Shopify

Payment icons

choosing a selection results in a full page refresh